I too am confused as to what is going on. Why not just start a thread here and tell everyone interested to vote here. Anyway, was thinking of this going forward. If a player has a freshman or a red shirt freshman on his roster then he may keep him for the next year and that year only. Then he goes back into the pool. If the freshMan red shirts his soph year then he's gone into the pool as a RS Soph. Same for red shirt fresh. If he for any reason: Injury. Olympic RS, whatever reason he doesn't wrestle his RS Soph year, he too is into the general pool. A freshman or RS Freshman can be kept for the next year and the next year only irregardless if the circumstances.
That way those who like to study and/or gamble or have coached a kid in high school or whatever can have said wrestler for the max of 2 years possibly. At that point he again is a free agent so to speak. It allows for those who like to gamble and brag about they knew the kid was good or who are just fortuidous enough can reap the rewards while not bogarting a david taylor for 4 years.
Whaddy think???